Transformation is a major theme developing by implication
from the observations made so far. On the basis of our observations we would say the following
Many teachers and schools now have a substantial number of years experience with ICT in classrooms (typically
5 to 20 years).
In most situations there is the hope that the incorporation of ICT will bring about
some transformation
of teaching and learning programs.
Transformations have been achieved in most situations. However these
transformations have largely been temporary and often situational (made meaningful and possible by remote circumstances).
In this sense they can be considered episodic.
Thus there is a need to consider sustainable transformation involving ICT.
Paradoxically authentic teaching and online learning are potential constraints in the achievement of a sustained transformation of schools, teaching and learning.
Of these
- authentic teaching is at least in part culturally determined so that
teacher directed learning may be the agreed concept of 'authentic teaching' and
- online learning (as an possible component of authentic pedagogy) is in part technologically dependent
- and technology may not be reliable (many teachers explain that dependency
on technology can be a risky business)
There is little or no evidence to support the converse, that is, the provision of reliable technology does not appear to lead
directly to substantial transformation of
teaching and learning.
The use of ICT to target a specific elements of teaching and learning is often
associated with transformation.
Sustained transformation 1. Teaching to learning
One Tasmanian training facility is using WebCT to engage students in learning through self-testing.
The self-testing takes students well beyond the immediate course materials and
challenges their understanding of the course 'content' . This has transformed
the core of the program from teaching to learning. The staff team is convinced that
their approach is very sustainable.
On the other hand, they are finding that their approach is not readily 'transferable' to their colleagues.
A possible explanation involves mismatched notions of authentic teaching, lack
of confidence about compliance with system requirements and perhaps other cultural
factors.
Other similar interstate training systems are interested in their approach and it may be transferable to them
perhaps because of matching notions of authentic teaching and a similar culture.
Temporary transformation 2. Real history and geography
Another example is of the teacher whose class used email extensively while her parents were travelling Australia.
The class followed the travellers closely and learned a great deal about other
parts of the country. This has proved not to be sustainable: the parents are no longer travelling and the class is not
in communication with others elsewhere.
Sustainability of authentic teaching incorporating ICT is almost certainly going to be project
focused in an ongoing way. In projects there is information to be gathered, things to be done, and
products to be produced and shared... Just the sort of activities to which ICT
can contribute...see constructing
knowledge.
Our 20 year history of computers in classrooms is overwhelming evidence that
ICT will not directly cause transformation but that it can be used to support transformation.
So what might be involved in sustainable
transformation?
|